Guillermo del Toro’s Frankenstein: Only One Scene Shows Us Mary Shelley’s Monster
Jacob Elordi as the Creature is the hero of del Toro’s Frankenstein, but one scene delivers the terrifying ‘daemon’ described in the novel.
Guillermo del Toro’s Frankenstein is now one year old and I have freshly revisited it, specifically the new Reborn Cut that restores a vital eight minutes. But I want to talk about one scene that is in both cuts. One of my favorite parts of the whole movie, and the only moment in the movie where the Creature genuinely lives up to the word “Monster." It’s also an invention of the movie, not found in Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus.
In the Arctic, the Creature (Jacob Elordi) attacks Victor Frankenstein’s (Oscar Isaac) camp, pulling his creator from his tent into the blistering cold. Several painful strikes later, the Creature nicks a dynamite stick from Victor’s coat. Piecing together Victor’s prayers that the explosive might be enough to kill him, the Creature makes his creator a bet; Victor will light the dynamite, if it does kill him they’re both free — but if it doesn’t, he will come to hurt Victor again. The sound of the subsequent explosion, which again fails to kill the Creature (leaving him only some rapidly-healed burns) is how the Horizon crew stumbles onto both Victor and the Creature.
Guillermo del Toro’s Frankenstein makes the Creature the outright hero of the story, not merely a sympathetic victim or a tragic villain. But then we come to that scene with the dynamite, and finally we see the Creature who Shelley wrote: The one who murders William upon hearing that his name is “Frankenstein,” who frames an innocent woman for his crime because he adores her sleeping face and hates that she would surely cower from his, and who murders Elizabeth on her wedding night to spite his absentee father.
A prayer candle of dynamite
Again, the dynamite scene is nowhere in the novel, though it might be inspired by the Creature’s demise there. The Creature swears he will end his own life, specifically with fire so that no trace of his creation might remain on Earth. In the movie, his rapidly regenerating body means he can’t die, which is why he puts the dynamite to the test with self harm. Therein also lies the beautiful symbolism of the scene; the Creature actually wants the dynamite to kill him, and he’s framed holding it close to his chest, like a prayer candle or a treasured object he hopes might be his salvation.
Throughout del Toro’s Frankenstein, the Creature attacks only in self-defense… except here. Earlier the Creature swore to Victor, “If you are not to award me love, I will indulge in rage!” His strength, and violent application thereof, is a tool of pain reserved only for Victor, and the Creature has quickly learned to enjoy making him hurt.
But wait, doesn’t the movie open with the Creature rampaging through the Horizon crew? There, be mindful that the crew shoot at him first. He moves like an enormous wraith, an image complemented by how his face remains concealed behind his scarf. There’s dispassion in the violence, too, like he’s pushing objects out of his path and nothing more.
“Dispassion” is definitely not a word you can use to describe the Creature’s dialogue in the dynamite scene: “Victor… you only listen when I hurt you!” The terrifying beauty of that line is how it sounds so much like something an abusive parent would say to a child. Del Toro refashioned Frankenstein to explore the cycle of how abused sons become abusive fathers. The Creature’s abuse, though, rebounds onto the father who chained, struck, and attempted to kill him.
Victor trapped him in endless suffering by bringing him to life with a face that frightens people. The Creature ensures his creator shares in pain in the bluntest ways he can. He’s also playing with his prey in the way that, say, the wolves seen earlier during “The Creature’s Tale” never would. When the Creature makes Victor light the dynamite in front of both their faces, he pulls down his scarf so that Victor can glimpse his sadistic smile. Then as the fuse sparks, the Creature warns Victor, “Run!”, and you can tell he’s having fun leaving Victor terrified.
What makes the Creature smile like that in Shelley’s novel? Compare this passage from the 1818 edition of Frankenstein. Victor discovers Elizabeth, murdered by the Creature in proxy revenge for Victor refusing to imbue life into Adam’s requested Eve.
“I saw at the open window a figure the most hideous and abhorred. A grin was on the face of the monster; he seemed to jeer, as with his fiendish finger he pointed towards the corpse of my wife.”
Shelley’s Creature resented the world and the human race itself for spurning him at every turn, and so he began to relish the lives he took as recompense. Elordi and del Toro’s Creature focuses his wrath only upon Victor himself. But this scene proves that Elordi could’ve played the Creature’s nihilistic and vengeful side as masterfully as he did his curiosity and anguish. The movie denies us more of that.
Is Guillermo del Toro softening Frankenstein’s Monster a fault?
Before Frankenstein’s release, I had expected a faithful beat for beat adaptation. Such a Frankenstein movie was still something Hollywood hadn’t quite achieved. It’s been tried, for sure, by both Kenneth Branagh and the Hallmark Channel, but neither was grand enough to be definitive. My thinking was del Toro — Frankenstein obsessive that he is — would pursue his love for the story like Victor Frankenstein himself seeking to ignite the spark of life.
But now, it seems obvious that of course del Toro didn’t do that. He reveres James Whale’s Frankenstein, too, so how could he be expected to write out that film’s impact on the story? (The doctor at first keeping the Monster imprisoned comes from that, but with the new child-rearing text and imagery.) While del Toro adores Mary Shelley, it was foolish to assume an artist as expressive and idiosyncratic as him was just going to transcribe someone else’s work. What would be the point of that? The world has changed a lot since 1818, and Frankenstein has been retold many times.
Now, del Toro softens the novel’s conflict with thicker shades of black and white. Everyone knows the “Doctor Frankenstein is the real monster” reading (this movie does), but the tragedy of Frankenstein doesn’t end there. The Creature is a monster by the end of the story, but because of his actions, not his unnatural birth or the appearance on which everyone condemns him at first sight. Del Toro is enamored by the potential for goodness the Creature shows in the novel. That goodness is snuffed out by the world’s cruelty and people’s judgmental hatred, and instead, del Toro crafts his narrative to nourish it.
Del Toro taking the Creature’s side does mean the movie loses much of the novel’s horror, because that horror is from Victor’s perspective. His life is systematically destroyed, and his loved ones murdered one-by-one, by a Creature beyond his capacity to defeat. It’s all his fault for abandoning the Creature, yes, but the book allows us to see Victor as both villain and victim simultaneously.
The last section of the flashbacks as Victor hunts the Monster is the most ominous and dreadful stretch of the story. His fate is intertwined with an unstoppable murderer and one that’s already destroyed his family. All that’s left for him is to chase this Creature to the ends of the world, and Shelley’s prose conveys how long and far Victor keeps pushing himself.
“I have traversed a vast portion of the earth, and have endured all the hardships which travellers, in deserts and barbarous countries, are wont to meet. How I have lived I hardly know; many times have I stretched my failing limbs upon the sandy plain, and prayed for death. But revenge kept me alive; I dared not die, and leave my adversary in being […] I have endured misery, which nothing but the eternal sentiment of a just retribution burning within my heart could have enabled me to support.” - Frankenstein Volume 3, Chapter VII
In the movie, the Creature demanding a companion is oddly compressed, as is Victor then hunting him.
In The Modern Prometheus, as Victor concludes his tale and realizes his time is short, he warns Captain Walton to beware of the Creature.
“He is eloquent and persuasive; and once his words had even power over my heart: but trust him not. His soul is as hellish as his form, full of treachery and fiend-like malice.”
But are we to take Victor’s words as accurate judgement? The Creature has both spoken sad words of how the world, and his father, rejected him without giving him a chance and then throttled innocent women and children, too. Victor is also unwavering in his belief he’s the more just one yet aware he has not the life left to complete his vengeance; he is explicitly imploring Walton to take up his sword.
Even when the Creature comes aboard the ship, Walton is struck with “curiousity and compassion” for the Creature mourning his father. The Creature, too, protests he never truly enjoyed his rampage:
“Think ye that the groans of Clerval were music to my ears? My heart was fashioned to be susceptible of love and sympathy; and, when wrenched by misery to vice and hatred, it did not endure the violence of the change without torture such as you cannot even imagine.”
Walton’s stance throughout the scene is cautious, as if sympathetic but still wary from how Victor described the Creature. His concluding verdict is that the Creature’s torment does not excuse his actions, for he could’ve still “listened to the voice of conscience, and heeded the stings of remorse.” Then the Creature admits the true feeling that drove him most of all: Envy, for he saw how the selfish creator who had abandoned him still enjoyed a happiness and family that the Creature never would.
Both Victor and the Creature die believing they’re the one who suffered more than the other, even if both of them will also separately admit they weren’t innocent either. That’s why I found del Toro’s abridgement of the ending in Frankenstein as moving as a lightning strike to the heart. Victor imploring his creation to keep living, and the Creature granting his forgiveness, felt like del Toro metatextually reaching back to give the leads of the novel a reconciliation that the world and their own flaws previously denied them.

Discussion about this post